Dr. Brown's vs Comotomo pits the most recommended anti-colic bottle against the most-reviewed bottle for breastfed babies. Comotomo's squishy silicone body and wide nipple are built to feel like a breast; Dr. Brown's internal vent is built to keep air out of the milk. They are both excellent and they suit different babies. Here is how Dr. Brown's Options+ and Comotomo compare.
Quick Verdict
Choose Comotomo if your baby is breastfed and refusing bottles, or if you want the easiest bottle to clean: three pieces, wide mouth, silicone that goes in the dishwasher or microwave sterilizer. Choose Dr. Brown's if your baby is gassy, colicky, or refluxy, or was born early and needs a preemie flow; its vent system is more effective than any nipple valve. If a baby takes both, Comotomo wins on convenience.
Dr. Brown's Options+ vs Comotomo at a Glance
| Dr. Brown's Options+ Narrow | Comotomo | |
|---|---|---|
| Body | Rigid BPA-free plastic (glass available) | Soft, squeezable silicone |
| Anti-colic | Internal vent tube and insert, removable | Dual air vents in the nipple |
| Parts | 6 per bottle | 3 per bottle plus cap |
| Nipple | Narrow, gradual slope, preemie to Y-cut flows | Extra wide, breast-like mound, slow to variable flows |
| Sizes | 2, 4, 8 oz | 5 and 8 oz |
| Cleaning | Hand wash with vent brush; top rack | Dishwasher, boil, microwave sterilizer; wide mouth |
| Amazon rating | 4.7 stars, 38,000+ ratings | 4.7 stars, 64,000+ ratings |
| Price | About $22 for four 8 oz | About $25 for two 8 oz |
Breast to Bottle
Comotomo is the bottle most often bought for a breastfed baby who has rejected everything else. The nipple is a wide, soft mound rather than a stalk, and the whole bottle gives under a baby's hands the way a breast does. Many babies who refuse rigid bottles accept it. It is not a guarantee, since babies have individual preferences, but it is the usual next attempt after a standard bottle fails.
Dr. Brown's narrow nipple also encourages a deep latch with its gradual slope, and its slow and preemie flows let a breastfed baby work at a nursing pace without being flooded. Babies who like a firmer nipple often prefer it.
Gas and Colic
Dr. Brown's vent system channels air to the back of the bottle so it never bubbles through the milk, which produces a steady, vacuum-free feed and less swallowed air. For babies with real gas or reflux, parents consistently report the biggest improvement from Dr. Brown's. Comotomo's two nipple vents prevent vacuum and nipple collapse and reduce air intake, which is enough for most babies but less effective for the gassiest.
Cleaning
Comotomo wins decisively. The mouth is wide enough to clean with a hand and a cloth, there are three pieces, and the silicone tolerates the dishwasher, boiling, and microwave sterilizing without clouding. Dr. Brown's has six pieces, a thin vent tube that needs its own brush, and takes noticeably longer across a day of feeds. Removing the vent later simplifies it.
Handling
Comotomo's soft body is easy for a baby to hold, but the base is wide, so it does not fit many bottle warmers, drying racks, and cup holders, and the silicone picks up lint. Dr. Brown's narrow bottle fits everything and is less likely to leak when carried upright, though it can leak if shaken with the vent installed.
Who Should Buy Dr. Brown's Options+
Babies with gas, colic, reflux, or a preemie flow need, and parents who want the widest range of flow levels and sizes.
Check Dr. Brown's Options+ Price on Amazon
Who Should Buy Comotomo
Breastfed babies refusing bottles, and parents who prioritize fast cleaning and a soft, natural feel.
Check Comotomo Price on Amazon
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Comotomo leak?
It can if the collar is not screwed on evenly, which is easy to do on the soft body. Tighten until it stops, not beyond, and check the nipple is seated flat.
Which bottle is better for a newborn?
Both work from birth with their slowest nipples. Dr. Brown's offers a preemie flow, which Comotomo does not, so for very small or premature babies Dr. Brown's is the safer start.
Can you use Comotomo without the vents?
The vents are built into the nipple and cannot be removed. They rarely cause problems, but if milk flows too fast, drop to a slower nipple rather than changing the vents.
