What changed in this May 2026 update: We re-checked The Honest Company's full product lineup against the latest EWG Skin Deep ratings and the active CPSC recall list. Refreshed price ranges, added context on the 2024-2025 reformulation cycle, and updated our take on the brand's clean-beauty positioning. Next scheduled review: August 2026.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you.
Last updated: April 2026 | Reviewed by the YourHappyBaby editorial team
The Honest Company was founded in 2012 by actress Jessica Alba after she experienced a reaction to conventional laundry detergent while pregnant. The founding story — a celebrity founder, a personal health motivation, a commitment to safer ingredients — drove early adoption among new parents willing to pay a premium for what they believed were better formulations. More than a decade later, The Honest Company is a public company (HNST), widely distributed in Target, Walmart, and Amazon, and the category-defining name in "clean" mainstream baby products.
With that scale has come more scrutiny. The brand has faced lawsuits over product labeling claims, ingredient controversies, and price comparisons with competitors who meet similar clean standards at lower price points. This review evaluates each product category honestly: what's genuinely worth buying, what's overpriced for what it delivers, and how the full product line compares to alternatives.
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Category | Rating | Value | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Honest Diapers | Diapers | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Excellent with subscription | $$$ |
| Honest Baby Wipes | Wipes | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Strong value | $$ |
| Honest Shampoo & Body Wash | Cleanser | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Good | $$ |
| Honest Baby Healing Balm | Skin Barrier | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Solid | $ |
| Honest Sensitive Baby Lotion | Moisturizer | ⭐⭐⭐ | Average — better alternatives exist | $$ |
| Honest Diaper Rash Cream | Diaper Rash | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Good | $ |
| Honest Bubble Bath | Bath | ⭐⭐⭐ | Skip — use body wash instead | $ |
| Honest Calming Lavender Shampoo | Cleanser | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Good for older babies | $$ |
Product-by-Product Review
1. The Honest Company Diapers — Best Honest Product
The Honest Company Diapers
Honest Diapers use a plant-based core (sustainably harvested fluff pulp) with a soft, chlorine-free inner layer and printed outer designs. No fragrances, no lotions, no latex. Absorption performance is competitive with premium conventional diapers including Pampers Pure and Huggies Special Delivery. The subscription model (available through Honest's website and Amazon Subscribe & Save) reduces the per-diaper cost to a level competitive with premium conventional brands. Honest diapers are designed with a stretchy waistband and leg cuffs that reduce blowout incidents — a frequent complaint with conventional designs at this price tier. Available in Newborn through Size 6.
- Plant-based core, chlorine-free processing, no fragrances or lotions
- Absorption competitive with Pampers Pure and Huggies Special Delivery
- Stretchy waistband and leg cuffs reduce blowout incidents
- Subscription pricing makes cost competitive
- Wide pattern variety — popular visual design element
- Available Newborn through Size 6
- Higher per-diaper cost without subscription
- Some parents report absorption differences between individual print runs
- Subscription model requires advance planning for size changes
- Some families find conventional diaper brands more absorbent for heavy wetters overnight
The Honest diaper is the brand's strongest product category and the clearest justification for the brand's existence. The combination of plant-based materials, chlorine-free processing, no fragrance or lotion additives, and absorption that genuinely competes with premium conventional options makes it a defensible choice over Pampers and Huggies for families who prioritize clean materials. The subscription model closes the price gap significantly — on Subscribe & Save, Honest diapers cost roughly the same per-unit as Pampers Pure, which is the most comparable conventional premium option.
Pros
- Clean materials with competitive absorption
- Subscription pricing closes cost gap vs. conventional premium diapers
- Stretchy design reduces blowout incidents
Cons
- More expensive without subscription
- Occasional batch consistency variability reported
2. Honest Baby Wipes — Best Value Honest Product
Honest Baby Wipes
Honest Baby Wipes use plant-derived cloth with a water-based solution containing aloe vera, chamomile extract, and a minimal preservative blend. No alcohol, no parabens, no fragrance. Dermatologist-tested and hypoallergenic. The wipes are notably thick and durable compared to budget wipes, resisting tearing during use. The bulk pack pricing through Amazon Subscribe & Save brings the per-wipe cost to one of the lowest among clean baby wipes — competitive with WaterWipes on a per-unit basis while offering the aloe and chamomile formulation benefit. The flip-top dispenser pack is well-designed for one-handed access.
- Plant-derived cloth, water-based, no alcohol or parabens
- Aloe and chamomile formula
- Thick, durable — resists tearing
- Bulk Subscribe & Save pricing competitive with WaterWipes
- Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested
- Well-designed flip-top dispenser
- Not as minimal as WaterWipes (2 ingredients) — more complex formula
- Some parents prefer the pure-water simplicity of WaterWipes for newborns under 3 months
- Flip-top can dry out wipes if not firmly closed
The Honest wipes occupy the sweet spot between WaterWipes' two-ingredient minimalism and conventional wipes' 15+ ingredient formulations. For families who want more than just water (the aloe and chamomile formula provides some soothing benefit) without the full conventional ingredient list, Honest wipes are the cleanest mainstream wipe available at mass-retail prices. After three months when newborn skin has matured, many parents transition from WaterWipes to Honest wipes as their everyday option.
Pros
- Clean mainstream wipe with aloe and chamomile
- Competitive bulk pricing
- Thick, durable cloth construction
Cons
- More ingredients than WaterWipes — some parents prefer simpler for newborns
3. Honest Conditioning Detangling Shampoo & Body Wash — Best Honest Cleanser
The Honest Company Shampoo, Body Wash & Conditioner Duo
A 2-in-1 cleansing shampoo and body wash paired with a conditioner, made with naturally derived, tear-free ingredients. The duo cleans and detangles fine baby hair while staying gentle on sensitive skin.
- Tear-free cleansing and conditioning
- Helps detangle fine hair
- Naturally derived ingredients
- Conditioner is light, thick hair may need more
The conditioning benefit is what distinguishes this from the Puracy and Attitude alternatives earlier in this guide. For babies under 6 months with minimal hair, a standard gentle wash is sufficient. From 6 months onward as hair thickens, the silk amino acid conditioning makes post-bath combing meaningfully easier, which matters at bath time when a baby who protests hair-combing creates a frustration point.
Pros
- Silk amino acid conditioning for post-bath combing ease
- No sulfates, parabens, or synthetic fragrances
- Widely available at mass retailers
4. Honest Baby Healing Balm — Best Honest Multipurpose Balm
The Honest Company Soothing Baby Bottom Wash
A no-rinse soothing wash that gently cleanses and refreshes a baby's bottom at diaper changes. The naturally derived formula is a fuss-free alternative to wipes for sensitive skin.
- Gentle no-rinse cleansing
- Soothes sensitive skin
- Handy at diaper changes
- Needs a cloth or cotton to apply
The Honest Healing Balm is the right choice for parents who want a plant-based Aquaphor alternative. The petrolatum-free formulation is appropriate for families avoiding petroleum derivatives, and the calendula addition provides the anti-inflammatory benefit absent from pure petrolatum products. For routine dry skin and mild irritation, it performs comparably to Aquaphor. For severe eczema or significant skin barrier compromise, the occlusive strength of petrolatum remains clinically superior — this is a philosophical tradeoff, not a performance one for routine use.
Pros
- Plant-based Aquaphor alternative without petrolatum
- Calendula anti-inflammatory benefit
- Tube format for portability
Cons
- Less occlusive than petrolatum for severe barrier compromise
- Tree nut caution for shea butter
5. Honest Sensitive Baby Lotion — Most Honest Assessment
Honest Sensitive Baby Lotion
- Fragrance-free daily moisturizer
- Lightweight texture absorbs without greasiness
- Widely available
- Clean conventional formulation
- Not EWG Verified — Pipette and Babo Botanicals are EWG Verified at similar prices
- No therapeutic active ingredient — basic glycerin-water-oil formula
- Does not justify brand premium over certified alternatives
- Not recommended for eczema — better specialized options available
This is the product where the Honest Company brand premium is hardest to justify. At the same $12–$14 price, Pipette Baby Lotion is EWG Verified with sugarcane squalane, and Babo Botanicals is EWG Verified with colloidal oatmeal and National Eczema Association acceptance. The Honest lotion is a competent everyday moisturizer that won't cause problems — but if you're paying for clean formulation, the certifications on the alternatives are more robust.
Pros
- Fragrance-free, lightweight, widely available
- Adequate for routine daily moisturizing
Cons
- Not EWG Verified despite clean-brand pricing
- Pipette and Babo Botanicals offer more for similar price
- Not appropriate as an eczema treatment
6. Honest Diaper Rash Cream — Best Budget Honest Skincare
Honest Diaper Rash Cream
Honest Diaper Rash Cream uses 9% zinc oxide as its active ingredient in a petroleum-free base of sunflower oil, shea butter, and beeswax. At 9% zinc oxide, it is a preventive and mild treatment formula — lower than the 40% zinc oxide in Desitin Maximum Strength, which is the clinical treatment standard. For mild rash and daily prevention use, the 9% concentration is effective and the petroleum-free base is a meaningful differentiator for families avoiding petroleum derivatives. Free from parabens, fragrances, and synthetic dyes.
- Petroleum-free zinc oxide cream
- 9% zinc oxide for prevention and mild rash treatment
- Sunflower oil and shea butter base
- Fragrance-free, paraben-free
- Suitable for cloth diapers (petroleum-free)
- Under $13
- 9% zinc oxide — significantly less potent than Desitin Maximum Strength (40%) for established rash
- For a severe rash, Desitin Maximum Strength will clear it faster
- Shea butter base — caution for tree nut allergy
The 9% vs 40% zinc oxide distinction matters practically: the Honest diaper rash cream is the right product for prevention and mild irritation, and the wrong product for an established moderate-to-severe rash. Many parents use both: Honest cream at every diaper change for prevention, switching to Desitin Maximum Strength when an actual rash appears, and returning to Honest cream once it clears. This two-product approach covers both the preference for petroleum-free daily use and the clinical effectiveness needed for treatment.
Pros
- Petroleum-free zinc oxide barrier
- Good for prevention and mild rash
- Cloth diaper safe
Cons
- 9% zinc oxide — use Desitin Maximum Strength for established rash treatment
- Not a one-product solution for all rash severity levels
7. Honest Bubble Bath — Honest Assessment: Skip It
Honest Bubble Bath
Honest Bubble Bath produces generous foam with a coconut-derived surfactant base and added aloe. No sulfates, no parabens, no synthetic fragrances. Tear-free. The formula is clean by bubble bath standards. The honest assessment: pediatric dermatologists and urologists generally discourage frequent bubble bath use for babies and toddlers, as the surfactants in any bubble bath — even clean formulations — can contribute to urinary tract irritation in young girls and general skin dryness from prolonged surfactant exposure. The Honest Body Wash used as a bath-time addition achieves a similar bathing experience with significantly less surfactant exposure.
- Clean formulation by bubble bath standards
- No sulfates or synthetic fragrances
- Tear-free
- Gentle coconut-derived surfactants
- Pediatricians generally discourage frequent bubble bath use — surfactants irritate the urinary tract and dry out skin
- Body wash used sparingly achieves the same bathing outcome with less surfactant exposure
- Not a product category that adds meaningful value to a baby bath routine
The recommendation to skip the bubble bath is not a formulation critique — it is a category critique. Bubble baths require enough surfactant to create foam, and prolonged soaking in a surfactant-rich bath dries out skin and can irritate mucous membranes. For adults and older children who enjoy bubble baths occasionally, a clean formulation like this one is fine. For regular baby bath use, the body wash is both more effective as a cleanser and less irritating as a bath environment.
Pros
- Clean formulation by bubble bath standards
- Tear-free and fragrance-free
Cons
- Bubble baths as a category discouraged by pediatric dermatologists for regular infant use
- Body wash is a better everyday alternative
8. Honest Truly Calming Lavender Shampoo & Body Wash — Best for Bedtime Routine
Honest Truly Calming Lavender Shampoo & Body Wash
Honest Truly Calming Lavender Shampoo & Body Wash uses a gentle coconut-derived cleansing base scented with natural lavender essential oil — making it the Honest Company's scented wash option for families who want a bedtime routine with an aromatherapy element. Lavender essential oil at the low concentrations used in cosmetics has a strong safety record and is one of the most studied botanical aromatherapy agents for sleep-related use. No sulfates, no parabens. Tear-free. The lavender scent is subtle and fades within 30–60 minutes of application, functioning as a bath-time sensory cue rather than a persistent fragrance.
- Natural lavender essential oil — calming aromatherapy element for bedtime routine
- No sulfates or parabens
- Tear-free
- Lavender at low concentration has strong safety record for infants
- Useful as a consistent sensory cue for sleep routine association
- Subtle scent — fades within an hour
- Contains lavender essential oil — not fragrance-free (do not use as a substitute for fragrance-free wash for sensitive or eczema-prone skin)
- Lavender has phytoestrogenic properties at high concentrations — at the levels in this wash the evidence is not clinically concerning, but parents with concerns can use the unscented version
- Not appropriate as primary daily wash for babies with fragrance sensitivity
Lavender in the bedtime bath is one of the few aromatherapy applications in infant care with meaningful supporting data. A randomized trial published in Early Human Development found that infants bathed with a lavender-scented wash showed lower cortisol levels and less crying, and spent more time in deep sleep post-bath than the control group. The mechanism is the familiar lavender scent functioning as a consistent sensory anchor for the sleep routine — a cue that bath equals bedtime. The Honest lavender wash does this at a mainstream price and a clean-enough formulation for most families.
Pros
- Natural lavender aromatherapy for bedtime routine
- Supporting research for lavender and infant sleep
- Clean formulation, tear-free
- Subtle scent fades within an hour
Cons
- Not fragrance-free — not for eczema-prone or fragrance-sensitive babies
- Use unscented version for babies with skin sensitivity
Honest Company: Brand Verdict
Where Honest Earns Its Price
- Diapers: Best-in-class for clean materials at a subscription price that's competitive with Pampers Pure
- Wipes: Best clean wipe at mainstream price for babies over 3 months
- Healing Balm: Best petroleum-free multi-use balm available at mainstream retail
- Lavender Bath Wash: Good bedtime routine tool with supporting research
Where Honest Doesn't Justify the Premium
- Sensitive Lotion: Pipette and Babo Botanicals are EWG Verified at the same price — choose those instead
- Bubble Bath: Category not recommended for regular infant use regardless of brand
How Honest Compares to Competitors
Versus Mustela: Mustela's skincare is more clinically focused (Stelatopia for eczema is the gold standard) and more expensive. For general use, Honest's price is more accessible. Mustela wins on specialized treatment products; Honest wins on everyday value and diaper/wipe quality.
Versus Burt's Bees Baby: Very similar positioning. Burt's Bees is slightly less expensive for most SKUs; Honest has the diaper advantage. Both are available at mass retail. Neither is EWG Verified across its full range.
Versus Puracy/Pipette/Babo Botanicals: For skincare specifically, these smaller brands often carry stronger certifications (EWG Verified) at competitive prices. Honest wins on brand breadth (diapers + wipes + skincare) and retail availability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Verdict
The Honest Company built its brand on a simple promise: safer ingredients than conventional baby products, accessible at mainstream retail. In its strongest categories — diapers and wipes — it delivers on that promise at prices that are competitive when buying on subscription. The Healing Balm and bath washes are genuinely good products. The Sensitive Lotion is the category to skip, where better-certified alternatives exist at the same price. Overall: a trustworthy brand for its core products, worth scrutinizing at the SKU level rather than buying the full line on brand trust alone.
Frequently asked questions (continued)
The Honest Company became EWG Verified in 2020 for most of its baby line and discloses 100% of ingredients including fragrance components. After a 2017 SLS controversy (when an SLS-based formula contradicted their "no SLS" marketing), the brand instituted third-party ingredient verification. Current products are independently audited annually.
Related reading from Your Happy Baby
- Mustela Baby Products Review
- Johnson Baby Products Review
- Frida Baby Products Review
- Munchkin Baby Products Review
